Corporate Transparency Act Held Constitutional

Corporate Transparency Ac…

Introduction

Several earlier pieces have described the tortured path of the U.S. Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), which introduced an extensive beneficial ownership reporting regime for non-exempt U.S. and overseas entities. After several regulatory iterations and in the face of substantial hostility from the small business community in the United States, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), an arm of the U.S. Treasury Department, issued a rule limiting enforcement of the CTA to non-U.S. entities that register to do business in a U.S. state.

In the meantime, a number of lawsuits have been brought attacking the legislation on constitutional grounds, notably that the CTA exceeds the authority of the federal government (the regulation of incorporation and business registration is reserved to the states). Two decisions in particular came before federal circuit courts of appeal.

Federal Court Decisions

In May 2024 a Texas retailer (Top Cop Shop) brought suit in federal district court, seeking a nationwide preliminary injunction against enforcement of the CTA and its associated FinCEN reporting rule. A federal district court in Texas granted the request, but the arms retailer's request for a nationwide preliminary injunction.

On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit confirmed the injunction, but in January of 2025 the Supreme Court paused the injunction (allowing enforcement of the scaled-back reporting requirement to proceed): the Texas plaintiff then petitioned the Supreme Court for full review of the constitutional position.

Separately, the National Small Business Association secured an injunction against enforcement of the CTA from a federal district court in Alabama in March of 2024, likewise on constitutional grounds. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the lower court decision in December of 2025, and the plaintiff sought Supreme Court review.

The Supreme Court Action

On the first day of its 2026-2027 term, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear both appeals, leaving in place the appellate courts' respective determinations that the CTA is consistent with the requirements of the U.S. Constitution.

Conclusion

Absent a successful petition for reconsideration by the Supreme Court, the CTA will have survived the outstanding constitutional challenges against it. In addition to permitting the continuing application of its reporting rule to non-exempt overseas entities, and unless further court challenges are made and succeed, any potential future decision by FinCEN to modify its latest pronouncement and restore the reporting rule's application to domestic entities would appear to be allowable.

We will advise of further developments as they occur.

Categories: English Blogs